We'd never seen Elf, which is't quite up there with "I've never seen Citizen Kane"*, but still, we like holiday movies and so we fixed that gap this holiday season.
Charming and silly. Or, silly and charming. I'm still not sure I believe James Caan's transformation (I'm not really even sure I'd believe that that guy would bail Buddy in the first place, before the paternity test, but I guess I'm cynical).
FuzzyCo grade: A-
* I have seen Citizen Kane.**
** I have, though, only seen 50 of the AFI 100, so there's a full 50% chance that some movie you think is great I haven't seen. Oh, Rocky. I haven't seen Rocky. Who hasn't seen Rocky? The guy with the thumbs, that's who.